Photo of sheet music being blown off music stand“The route to becoming an accomplished musician is seldom smooth and trouble free.”
The Musician’s Way, p. 202

We musicians may dream of performing brilliantly at every show or audition, but, in reality, things don’t always go as well as we’d like.

Especially for students, playing or singing under scrutiny can bring upsetting surprises: shakiness, memory slips, music wafting off the stand – you name it.

How can we learn from on-stage letdowns and bounce back stronger than before?

More than anything else, we develop resiliency by being able to evaluate our work objectively and devise solutions for problems. Then, with action plans in hand, we can head to the practice room empowered to progress.

Conversely, if we can’t grasp why something went wrong and see what to do about it, we tend to feel helpless.

The following tool helps rising musicians transform on-stage problems into artistic insights.

Performance Evaluation Tool, by Gerald Klickstein

Use this tool immediately following a practice performance or on the day after an audition or a public show. If possible, record the performance you evaluate.

1. Note three or more aspects of your performance that went well.
E.g., “The rhythmic groove was solid; the dynamic contrasts rocked; the tone was rich.”

2. Note specific things you’d like to improve before your next performance.
“Improve memory in second section and overall mental focus.”

3. Determine the reasons for your successes.
Cite what you did in practice to achieve the results you noted under item 1.

4. Specify action plans to achieve improvements.
Determine your practice plan to address the issues you noted under item 2. E.g., “Apply memorization strategies from Chapter 4 of The Musician’s Way; then practice performing to enhance my ability to focus under pressure.”

Psychologists Mitchell Robin and Rochelle Balter wrote, “One of the most difficult lessons that we must learn as humans is how to rate our behaviors and features without globally rating ourselves.” (Performance Anxiety, p. 179)

Although it’s challenging to size up our work objectively and not put ourselves down when we miss the mark, by acquiring the skills to do so, we gain the means to overcome performance problems, conquer stage fright, and grow our artistry without end.

Recommended portable digital recorders:

  • Zoom H4N PRO. Outstanding sound quality & features. A musician favorite!
  • Zoom H2n. An excellent option for self-study recording.
  • Zoom H6. Extraordinary six-track recorder with 24 bit, 96K capability.
  • Tascam DR-22WL. A less-expensive but good-quality choice.

See p. 203 of The Musician’s Way for a sample self-evaluation done by a student who used the above tool.

Related posts
Countering perfectionism
The growth mindset
The meaning in mistakes
Practicing Performance
Solving problems in practice

© 2011 Gerald Klickstein
Photo © Photosani, licensed from Shutterstock.com

Back to Top